- 08-22-2010, 01:45 PM #49Registered User
- Join Date
- Jul 2010
- Siu Lam, NT
By writing in the SCMP you would do us a service by bringing awareness to us parents. Thanks!
- 08-22-2010, 04:09 PM #50
So, by some previous posters' reasoning:
1) homeschooling should be outlawed UNLESS the parents are qualified teachers
2) for that matter, parents are children's first and most influential teachers, so they, too, should probably be qualified teachers...
I know that I'm taking this to an extreme, but really, that is in essence what it is you are saying, isn't it? NO ONE who is not "properly qualified" should be teaching your child.
So, for soccer classes, we should ONLY have professionally qualified coaches? Same for ballet? What about an art class?
Or are you limiting your requirements to primary & secondary schools? Except cupcakes has already insinuated that I shouldn't be teaching playgroups, I have no idea what I'm doing and that I am only in it for the $. I take great exception to this insinuation.
- 08-22-2010, 04:26 PM #51geocup Guest
It is my personal and professional opinion that anyone who 'teaches' children in Hong Kong should in fact be qualified in teaching and police checked. Why do some countries have rigorous requirements to meet when it comes to teaching and not Hong KOng?
- 08-22-2010, 05:14 PM #52
- 08-22-2010, 05:25 PM #53Bumps Guest
I agree with cupcakes, AmyH and Elise.
- 08-22-2010, 05:50 PM #54Registered User
- Join Date
- May 2005
"I am really baffled at the number of uneducated teachers in HK. I know, that where I am from, to teach kindergarten, you must at least have a degree in Early Childhood. Here it seems, to me, that anyone who speaks English can teach. I have been a teacher for over 15 years and it always surprises me that here, schools and parents allow un-educated teachers teach their little ones." (Cupcake)
To begin with, even if a teacher does not have a teaching degree, this does not warrant the label 'uneducated'. You could have a Masters in Education but never have set foot inside a classroom. Secondly, I do not know where you are from, but it wasn't until fairly recently (ie. within the last 20 years) that other Western countries required teaching degrees/diplomas for all teaching staff. In the UK and Australia, it wasn't until the early 90's that all secondary staff were held to this standards, and it slowly trickled down as we became more and more aware of the importance of early education.
Hong Kong is not quick to change (skyline notwithstanding) - but the EDB is slowly 'catching up' to the standards held elsewhere. Based on my experience, close to 100% of staff at International schools in HK are registered teachers (for which you MUST have an educational qualification). Local schools are slowly changing - all people wanting to teach in a school must complete a PGCE (or equivalent).
You get entrenched staff anywhere: and you get staff who have great qualifications and zero ability to communicate with students in a classroom.
You have to remember that the kind of staff you are demanding come with a very particular price tag - and many people simply cannot afford to pay it.
I think it's also really important to be clear when you are discussing matters of language and ethnicity and country-of-origin exactly what the context is. Native English speakers do not all speak the same way, nor do they all follow the same rules or grammar. By the same token, there are 'local' graduates teaching English who may have wonderful grammar and syntax.
Education vs Experience is always a tricky one. In my experience, my education did not necessarily prepare me for all the demands of teaching in a classroom - there is certainly something to be said for on-the-job training! I do not know a teacher who does not say that they learned more in their first year of teaching than they did in their teaching degree/diploma.
Perhaps I say this from a teacher's perspective, but most parents I know do not need to ask about qualifications, because they can tell if a teacher is doing their job well or poorly. Benchmarks are great, but not everyone fits the same pigeonhole.
I fully support police checks, and believe me, they are coming. The EBD is just trying to work out how to administer a system where a good proportion of the teaching workforce has spent time in multiple countries/outside of HK. After several high profile cases involving staff at both local and ESF/International schools, it's on their radar.
- 08-22-2010, 06:01 PM #55geocup Guest
There is certainly something to be said about on the job training- absolutely - but this must be coupled with TEACHING education. From my point of view, at my school, this is not. The problem I see at my school, is that parents DO NOT know if their child is being taught correctly.. That is my point. Parents think that just because their child is coming home happy - that they are being taught correctly! Not so.
(Also, from where I am from it is a requirement to spend a significant amount of time in the class room if they are to attain an MEd).
I am all for police checks
- 08-22-2010, 06:45 PM #56Registered User
- Join Date
- Jan 2009
- Hong Kong
Cara - yes, you are taking it to an extreme. We never mentioned parents and sports coaches here. The teaching profession instantly acknowledges parents as the child's first teacher, and then they work as a team!
HappyV - don't know where you're from but speaking for myself - my DipTeach and BEd all required practical classroom experience - graduated 1979. I was practical teaching in my first year of university at 18. Practicums ( in length and expectations) steadily increased throughout my 4 years. UK is very much like Australia. I train teachers now. Many in local schools only have certificates. As I mentioned, lowered tiered international schools ideally would like BEds+ but their pay, demands and style of management are less than acceptable.
As I also mentioned, there is no need for parents to march up to their ESF or top tier international schools tomorrow requesting teachers' credentials. Good schools provide ongoing professional development for teachers and teacher monitoring is effectively implemented.
The use of the word 'uneducated' by the OP was unfortunate.
- By tstmum in forum EducationReplies: 4Last Post: 01-18-2011, 11:38 AM
- By Hannah's Mom in forum EducationReplies: 2Last Post: 11-30-2009, 08:54 AM
- By mushi in forum Everything ElseReplies: 2Last Post: 12-04-2008, 09:11 AM
- By rani in forum EducationReplies: 3Last Post: 01-03-2007, 12:06 AM
- By emilyc in forum EducationReplies: 8Last Post: 05-12-2005, 07:12 PM